Espandi menu
cerca
Decalogo 4

Regia di Krzysztof Kieslowski vedi scheda film

Recensioni

L'autore

Aquilant

Aquilant

Iscritto dal 9 ottobre 2004 Vai al suo profilo
  • Seguaci 23
  • Post -
  • Recensioni 354
  • Playlist 100
Mandagli un messaggio
Messaggio inviato!
Messaggio inviato!
chiudi

La recensione su Decalogo 4

di Aquilant
8 stelle

"How long have you known it?" asks Anka, giving voice to her emotions. She bears clear marks of suffering in her face. Her eyes are veiled with tears. "I don't know for certain, but I have always suspected it," Michal answers, "it doesn't matter anyway, you've been always my daughter for me!" "You have deceived me. But you should have told it to me!" tells Anka with a quiver in her voice, cutting a long story short. Sprinkled with a sublime and intense poetic vein, imbued with a touch of adolescential romanticism, full of subtle little nuances and pulsating waves of musicality, “Dekalog 4: Honour thy father and thy mother" is a despairing example of an uncommon and ambiguous father-daughter relationship close to being incestuous, named "Elektra complex", a feeling of deep affective attraction similar to Oedipus complex with both sex-roles reversed. Kieslowski describes with great clearness of mind the shadows of passion and the anomalous attitude of a teenager who "clings to love-life" with all the impetuousness of her young age, showing an air of contemptuous indifference and disdainful attitude, completely scornful about any codes for moral behavior and ethics, taking great pleasure in hurting his father's feelings and urged by her restlessness to make spiteful and irreversible death choices (a procured abortion) to take her revenge against a kind of paternal affection mistaken for morbid love. “Dekalog 4” is a real life drama comparable to a Pandora's box spreading ill-smelling effluvia all over the troubled world of two human beings caught in a perverse trap and bound to come to a painful compromise, on the point of facing a future full of uncertainties about their relationship. So the two characters are trapped in a net made of subtle cause-effect concatenations, woven by the director himself to divert the course of the story in a moral and ethical direction, turning a juvenile passion into an intense, palpable frustration in consequence of an unsuccessful crossing of the last moral divide. The unavoidable generational conflict is outlined without eschewing authorial involvement, bringing back some suffering Bergmanian memories of life but lived with a less despairing soul predisposition, far from any "Munchian screams". The open rebellion against a distressing existential pilgrimage of souls in torment and the precarious human condition in search of opportunities assume a different aspect in Kieslowski who, even if skeptical of any religious problems, bestows a touch of decisional attitude on his characters to allow them to make less defeatist choices and to face life with serenity. Maybe the best episode of the whole Dekalog series: "between the fire of the passion and his fire-extinguisher patiently arranged" says a famous French movie critic.

Ti è stata utile questa recensione? Utile per Per te?

Commenta

Avatar utente

Per poter commentare occorre aver fatto login.
Se non sei ancora iscritto Registrati